Damage Description – Arma 3
(Major revamp to remove redundant config property descriptions; added/expanded section on penetration & ballistics) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[Category:Arma 3: Tutorials]] | [[Category:Arma 3: Tutorials]] | ||
[[Category:Arma 3: Editing]] | |||
{{Cfg ref|start}} | |||
=Intro= | =Intro= | ||
An ongoing investigation on how damage and armor actually works in Arma 3. (Currently this is based on Olds research during the creation of the Real Armor Mod.) | An ongoing investigation on how damage and armor actually works in Arma 3. (Currently this is based on Olds research during the creation of the Real Armor Mod.) | ||
= | =The Damage Process= | ||
[[File:Olds damage diagram sm.gif]] | [[File:Olds damage diagram sm.gif]] | ||
==Pre-impact | |||
(1) A projectile is headed for the target. (For our discussion let's assume its a kinetic round on track for a direct hit vs. an AFV) | ==Pre-impact== | ||
(Diagram 1) A projectile is headed for the target. (For our discussion let's assume its a kinetic round on track for a direct hit vs. an AFV) | |||
==Initial Impact== | ==Initial Impact== | ||
(2) The projectile impacts the target. It has not penetrated any armor yet. And if it doesn't have the ballistics to go further it will terminate here doing only this initial damage. Regardless, the following things happen: | (Diagram 2) The projectile impacts the target. It has not penetrated any armor yet. And if it doesn't have the ballistics to go further it will terminate here doing only this initial damage. Regardless, the following things happen: | ||
Every major location on the target takes some damage. The location nearest the impact point gets the most, and it falls off geometrically. | Every major location on the target takes some damage. The location nearest the impact point gets the most, and it falls off geometrically. | ||
The target's global health is generally damaged the most. | The target's global health is generally damaged the most. | ||
| Line 14: | Line 18: | ||
That's right, some damage has already been done regardless of whether it's pistol-round vs. tank or sabot vs. bunny. | That's right, some damage has already been done regardless of whether it's pistol-round vs. tank or sabot vs. bunny. | ||
If the hit values are high enough, this initial impact alone can destroy the target (essentially by knocking out global health) ...regardless of penetration! | If the hit values are high enough, this initial impact alone can destroy the target (essentially by knocking out global health) ...regardless of penetration! | ||
==Penetrating Damage== | ==Penetrating Damage== | ||
(3) '' | (Diagram 3) ''If'' the projectile can penetrate the target's armor, it will continue moving and doing damage as it goes. Here's what happens: | ||
Every major location continues to take damage as in step 1. But something new happens as well... | Every major location continues to take damage as in step 1. But something new happens as well... | ||
...as the projectile travels past the armor it starts doing much more damage to the area immediately around itself. | ...as the projectile travels past the armor it starts doing much more damage to the area immediately around itself. | ||
| Line 23: | Line 28: | ||
Keep in mind there are (sometimes significant) variations to how this works for things like explosive weapons, indirectHit, deflections, etc. More on those below. And, yes, this description holds true for human targets (shoot someone in the hand, and their head will take some damage). | Keep in mind there are (sometimes significant) variations to how this works for things like explosive weapons, indirectHit, deflections, etc. More on those below. And, yes, this description holds true for human targets (shoot someone in the hand, and their head will take some damage). | ||
=Indirect & "Explosive" Damage= | =Indirect(Hit) & "Explosive" Damage= | ||
==IndirectHit== | ==IndirectHit== | ||
[[File:Olds_iHit_diagram_sm.gif]] | [[File:Olds_iHit_diagram_sm.gif]] | ||
| Line 33: | Line 38: | ||
And just as before, global health takes the most damage. | And just as before, global health takes the most damage. | ||
ranged indirectHit damage bypasses your armor and damages you anyway. Only the explosionShielding property can mitigate this. <!> Oddly, armor will protect you against direct hits with indirectHit weapons (need to investigate this further...). | ranged indirectHit damage bypasses your armor and damages you anyway. Only the explosionShielding property can mitigate this. <!> Oddly, armor will protect you against direct hits with indirectHit weapons (need to investigate this further...). | ||
==Explosive== | ==Explosive== | ||
Not the "explosion" effect you're thinking of--that's indirectHit. This weapon property does only one thing: it controls how much hit damage falls off with speed. | Not the "explosion" effect you're thinking of--that's indirectHit. This weapon property does only one thing: it controls how much hit damage falls off with speed. Weapons with no or 0 explosive value are considered fully 'kinetic' and lose hit value as they slow below their typicalSpeed. | ||
Weapons with no or 0 explosive value are considered fully 'kinetic' and lose hit value as they slow below their typicalSpeed. | |||
Weapons with explosive=1 are considered fully 'explosive' and do full damage regardless of the projectile speed. Values between 0 and 1 control the ratio of kinetic-to-explosive damage (i.e. explosive = 0.5 means half the damage falls off with speed and half does not). | Weapons with explosive=1 are considered fully 'explosive' and do full damage regardless of the projectile speed. Values between 0 and 1 control the ratio of kinetic-to-explosive damage (i.e. explosive = 0.5 means half the damage falls off with speed and half does not). | ||
<!> QUIRK! Values >=0.7 nullify a weapon's armor penetrating ability (as if caliber=0)!. Use values <0.7 if you want your weapon to have normal penetration behavior! | <!> QUIRK! Values >=0.7 nullify a weapon's armor penetrating ability (as if caliber=0)!. Use values <0.7 if you want your weapon to have normal penetration behavior! | ||
=Armor= | =Penetration & Ballistics, a digression...= | ||
I don't have much for this section so far as I haven't done | ==Bullet/Shell== | ||
Bullet/Shell ballistics are very simple and quite accurate. The only properties that influence trajectory are initSpeed (CfgMagazines) and airFriction (CfgAmmo). Such projectiles travel based on their muzzle velocity (initSpeed) and aerodynamic drag (airFriction), along with gravity-induced vertical drop. Penetration is simply a factor of (remaining projectile speed at impact) and (CfgAmmo.caliber). | |||
==Missile/Rocket== | |||
Missile/Rocket (let's call them M/R's) ballistics are more complex. However, unlike Bullet/Shell penetration--which works quite well--Missile & Rocket penetration is broken in the Arma 3 code. BI ignores penetration effects for these weapons and relies on exaggerated hit/indirectHit values to cause target damage. (RAM fixes this bug/limitation--and adds some new features along the way--with some minimal scripting). | |||
===Unguided=== | |||
These projectiles still use the same two properties as Bullet/Shells to determine their trajectories, but add some more (all in CfgAmmo): initTime, thrust, thrustTime maxSpeed. The four new properties account for the additional effect of a rocket motor: after "initTime", "thrust" is added to accelerate the projectile until it runs out ("thrustTime"), while "maxSpeed" puts a cap on the projectile's top speed. sideAirFriction & maneuvrability (from CfgAmmo) and mass (from the P3D model) get honorable mention here. But it's not clear that they add anything to the simulation of unguided M/R trajectories. | |||
===Guided=== | |||
These projectiles work as unguided M/R's above, but with added properties to account for the fact that they manuever to track a target. sideAirFriction is used like airFriction to create drag, but in the lateral axes (as the missile turns to follow a target). manuevrability controls the rate of turning ability (mass may also play a role here--in that higher mass M/R's have a harder time turning due to momentum--but testing is required to confirm this). There are also a few simple properties that pertain to how tracking is achieved, but they are beyond the scope of this discussion. | |||
=Armor (& RAM)= | |||
I don't have much for this section so far as I haven't done enough experimentation in this area. If you're porting/creating vehicles and want compatibility with RAM, here's some advice: | |||
Use the most detailed and accurate armor data you can when creating your vehicle's P3D Fire Geometry (armor). Correctly calibrated weapons are only going to give realistic results if your armor settings are good. | Use the most detailed and accurate armor data you can when creating your vehicle's P3D Fire Geometry (armor). Correctly calibrated weapons are only going to give realistic results if your armor settings are good. | ||
The armor material should generally be armour.bisurf (where thickness is defined by your model geometry). Preset-thickness materials (armour_plate, etc.) appear to respect LOS, so those should be fine too. | The armor material should generally be armour.bisurf (where thickness is defined by your model geometry). Preset-thickness materials (armour_plate, etc.) appear to respect LOS, so those should be fine too. | ||
Regardless of what the real vehicle uses for armor (aluminum, composite, etc.) | Regardless of what the real vehicle uses for armor (aluminum, composite, etc.) your best bet is to translate into RHA-equivalent (vs. kinetic) thickness. | ||
Internal structure should be blocked in crudely per the T-72 sample model: most/all hitpoint vertices should be inside geometry (e.g. the cast-iron modeled engine block) | Internal structure should be blocked in crudely per the T-72 sample model: most/all hitpoint vertices should be inside geometry (e.g. the cast-iron modeled engine block). BI/zGuba suggest a few should sit in empty space to respond to indirectHit damage better, but I haven't confirmed that. | ||
=Consequences & Implications= | =Consequences & Implications= | ||
| Line 57: | Line 73: | ||
Nor can the submunition feature be used as a workaround (it is also bugged for missiles if not other weapon types). | Nor can the submunition feature be used as a workaround (it is also bugged for missiles if not other weapon types). | ||
A script-based approach must be used to enable those weapon types to penetrate armor correctly. RAM contains such an approach. | A script-based approach must be used to enable those weapon types to penetrate armor correctly. RAM contains such an approach. | ||
=== | =Adjusting Config Properties for RAM= | ||
(See the [https://community.bistudio.com/wiki/Config_Properties_Megalist Config Properties Mega-List] for an explanation of the properties themselves). | |||
==Weapon-related Config Properties== | |||
===airFriction, caliber=== | |||
RAM adjusts caliber & airFriction values based on real-world data whenever possible. This yields accurate penetration values and ballistic trajectory. It corrects the Missile/Rocket penetration bug by editing those weapon types to create regular (bullet/shell based) projectile submunitions on impact, restoring penetration ability. (Rocket & Missile improvement cannot be achieved by adjusting vanilla configs - this requires script adjustment). | |||
===explosive=== | ===explosive=== | ||
RAM either caps explosive values at <0.7 to prevent the no-penetration bug, or creates a penetrating submunition (e.g. HEAT warheads). | |||
===hit=== | ===hit=== | ||
BI tends to greatly exaggerate hit values for large caliber weapons, while RAM generally reduces them values to prevent armor-overwhelming damage. | |||
==Vehicle Config Properties== | ==Vehicle Config Properties== | ||
===Global=== | ===Global:=== | ||
====armorStructural==== | ====armorStructural==== | ||
RAM generally ramps up these values to more or less cancel out the effect of global damage. (BI seems to have taken up the idea, and is creeping up armorStructural values in more recent configs). | |||
===Hit Location=== | |||
===Hit Location:=== | |||
====explosionShielding==== | ====explosionShielding==== | ||
These values are usually much lower in RAM than vanilla A3 (i.e. more protection against indirectHit). | |||
====passThrough==== | ====passThrough==== | ||
These tend to be zeroed out in RAM. | |||
====radius==== | ====radius==== | ||
[#>0,m?] the radius (in m?) of the location's hitpoint vertices in the vehicle's P3D model. The idea here is to spread the vertices throughout the internal structure such that they do not spill out into or beyond the vehicle's armor plates. Unless you have control over the P3D source file, you probably don't want to mess with this value. | [#>0,m?] the radius (in m?) of the location's hitpoint vertices in the vehicle's P3D model. The idea here is to spread the vertices throughout the internal structure such that they do not spill out into or beyond the vehicle's armor plates. Unless you have control over the P3D source file, you probably don't want to mess with this value. | ||
====HitTrack==== | ====HitTrack==== | ||
[location class] | [location class] Keeping in mind that this location generally has no armor geometry protecting it and is thus easily damaged by the slightest hit, RAM generally increases the protective properties of explosionShielding and minimalHit to make tracks more resistant to minor weapons. | ||
=Useful Links= | =Useful Links= | ||
| Line 123: | Line 117: | ||
[https://resources.bisimulations.com/w/index.php?title=Damage_Modeling:_Simulation VBS:Damage Modeling:Simulation Formulas] | [https://resources.bisimulations.com/w/index.php?title=Damage_Modeling:_Simulation VBS:Damage Modeling:Simulation Formulas] | ||
[https://community.bistudio.com/wiki/Config_Properties_Megalist Config Properties | [https://community.bistudio.com/wiki/Config_Properties_Megalist Config Properties Mega-List] | ||
{{Cfg ref|end}} | |||
Revision as of 21:29, 29 October 2014
Intro
An ongoing investigation on how damage and armor actually works in Arma 3. (Currently this is based on Olds research during the creation of the Real Armor Mod.)
The Damage Process
Pre-impact
(Diagram 1) A projectile is headed for the target. (For our discussion let's assume its a kinetic round on track for a direct hit vs. an AFV)
Initial Impact
(Diagram 2) The projectile impacts the target. It has not penetrated any armor yet. And if it doesn't have the ballistics to go further it will terminate here doing only this initial damage. Regardless, the following things happen: Every major location on the target takes some damage. The location nearest the impact point gets the most, and it falls off geometrically. The target's global health is generally damaged the most. Several factors affect the amount of damage taken: obviously the hit value of the weapon is important, but various weapon & target config values are also involved (minimalHit, explosive, etc.). That's right, some damage has already been done regardless of whether it's pistol-round vs. tank or sabot vs. bunny. If the hit values are high enough, this initial impact alone can destroy the target (essentially by knocking out global health) ...regardless of penetration!
Penetrating Damage
(Diagram 3) If the projectile can penetrate the target's armor, it will continue moving and doing damage as it goes. Here's what happens: Every major location continues to take damage as in step 1. But something new happens as well... ...as the projectile travels past the armor it starts doing much more damage to the area immediately around itself. Global health continues to get damaged and can really get clobbered now. BTW, this happens even if every passThrough value is set to zero(!). The projectile will terminate here or travel on through the target if it has penetration power remaining to do so.
Keep in mind there are (sometimes significant) variations to how this works for things like explosive weapons, indirectHit, deflections, etc. More on those below. And, yes, this description holds true for human targets (shoot someone in the hand, and their head will take some damage).
Indirect(Hit) & "Explosive" Damage
IndirectHit
This works pretty much as advertised--indirectHit represents damage from explosions (not to be confused with the BIS "explosive" property). indirectHit damage is applied whenever a weapon with that config property hits something (you, the ground, etc.) It causes damage out to 4x it's indirectHitRange (which is a radius), falling off linearly. If a target is within range (our trusty tank in the above diagram), it takes the same all-location damage described in part A. (The location closest to the impact takes the most damage and so on...) And just as before, global health takes the most damage. ranged indirectHit damage bypasses your armor and damages you anyway. Only the explosionShielding property can mitigate this. <!> Oddly, armor will protect you against direct hits with indirectHit weapons (need to investigate this further...).
Explosive
Not the "explosion" effect you're thinking of--that's indirectHit. This weapon property does only one thing: it controls how much hit damage falls off with speed. Weapons with no or 0 explosive value are considered fully 'kinetic' and lose hit value as they slow below their typicalSpeed. Weapons with explosive=1 are considered fully 'explosive' and do full damage regardless of the projectile speed. Values between 0 and 1 control the ratio of kinetic-to-explosive damage (i.e. explosive = 0.5 means half the damage falls off with speed and half does not). <!> QUIRK! Values >=0.7 nullify a weapon's armor penetrating ability (as if caliber=0)!. Use values <0.7 if you want your weapon to have normal penetration behavior!
Penetration & Ballistics, a digression...
Bullet/Shell
Bullet/Shell ballistics are very simple and quite accurate. The only properties that influence trajectory are initSpeed (CfgMagazines) and airFriction (CfgAmmo). Such projectiles travel based on their muzzle velocity (initSpeed) and aerodynamic drag (airFriction), along with gravity-induced vertical drop. Penetration is simply a factor of (remaining projectile speed at impact) and (CfgAmmo.caliber).
Missile/Rocket
Missile/Rocket (let's call them M/R's) ballistics are more complex. However, unlike Bullet/Shell penetration--which works quite well--Missile & Rocket penetration is broken in the Arma 3 code. BI ignores penetration effects for these weapons and relies on exaggerated hit/indirectHit values to cause target damage. (RAM fixes this bug/limitation--and adds some new features along the way--with some minimal scripting).
Unguided
These projectiles still use the same two properties as Bullet/Shells to determine their trajectories, but add some more (all in CfgAmmo): initTime, thrust, thrustTime maxSpeed. The four new properties account for the additional effect of a rocket motor: after "initTime", "thrust" is added to accelerate the projectile until it runs out ("thrustTime"), while "maxSpeed" puts a cap on the projectile's top speed. sideAirFriction & maneuvrability (from CfgAmmo) and mass (from the P3D model) get honorable mention here. But it's not clear that they add anything to the simulation of unguided M/R trajectories.
Guided
These projectiles work as unguided M/R's above, but with added properties to account for the fact that they manuever to track a target. sideAirFriction is used like airFriction to create drag, but in the lateral axes (as the missile turns to follow a target). manuevrability controls the rate of turning ability (mass may also play a role here--in that higher mass M/R's have a harder time turning due to momentum--but testing is required to confirm this). There are also a few simple properties that pertain to how tracking is achieved, but they are beyond the scope of this discussion.
Armor (& RAM)
I don't have much for this section so far as I haven't done enough experimentation in this area. If you're porting/creating vehicles and want compatibility with RAM, here's some advice:
Use the most detailed and accurate armor data you can when creating your vehicle's P3D Fire Geometry (armor). Correctly calibrated weapons are only going to give realistic results if your armor settings are good.
The armor material should generally be armour.bisurf (where thickness is defined by your model geometry). Preset-thickness materials (armour_plate, etc.) appear to respect LOS, so those should be fine too. Regardless of what the real vehicle uses for armor (aluminum, composite, etc.) your best bet is to translate into RHA-equivalent (vs. kinetic) thickness.
Internal structure should be blocked in crudely per the T-72 sample model: most/all hitpoint vertices should be inside geometry (e.g. the cast-iron modeled engine block). BI/zGuba suggest a few should sit in empty space to respond to indirectHit damage better, but I haven't confirmed that.
Consequences & Implications
In vanilla A3, the effects of armor are largely ignored by the damage system. More accurately: armor penetration is present, but its significance is overwhelmed by the global hitpoint effect--this is especially true for high damage-value weapons. Caliber-based ballistics work very well, but caliber is bugged for rockets & missiles (it can't be added). Nor can the submunition feature be used as a workaround (it is also bugged for missiles if not other weapon types). A script-based approach must be used to enable those weapon types to penetrate armor correctly. RAM contains such an approach.
Adjusting Config Properties for RAM
(See the Config Properties Mega-List for an explanation of the properties themselves).
airFriction, caliber
RAM adjusts caliber & airFriction values based on real-world data whenever possible. This yields accurate penetration values and ballistic trajectory. It corrects the Missile/Rocket penetration bug by editing those weapon types to create regular (bullet/shell based) projectile submunitions on impact, restoring penetration ability. (Rocket & Missile improvement cannot be achieved by adjusting vanilla configs - this requires script adjustment).
explosive
RAM either caps explosive values at <0.7 to prevent the no-penetration bug, or creates a penetrating submunition (e.g. HEAT warheads).
hit
BI tends to greatly exaggerate hit values for large caliber weapons, while RAM generally reduces them values to prevent armor-overwhelming damage.
Vehicle Config Properties
Global:
armorStructural
RAM generally ramps up these values to more or less cancel out the effect of global damage. (BI seems to have taken up the idea, and is creeping up armorStructural values in more recent configs).
Hit Location:
explosionShielding
These values are usually much lower in RAM than vanilla A3 (i.e. more protection against indirectHit).
passThrough
These tend to be zeroed out in RAM.
radius
[#>0,m?] the radius (in m?) of the location's hitpoint vertices in the vehicle's P3D model. The idea here is to spread the vertices throughout the internal structure such that they do not spill out into or beyond the vehicle's armor plates. Unless you have control over the P3D source file, you probably don't want to mess with this value.
HitTrack
[location class] Keeping in mind that this location generally has no armor geometry protecting it and is thus easily damaged by the slightest hit, RAM generally increases the protective properties of explosionShielding and minimalHit to make tracks more resistant to minor weapons.
Useful Links
See if you can pick out the useful data from the obsolete!